Civil society organisations submit proposals for quality in early childhood education

In a document submitted to the Undersecretary of Early Childhood Education, 24 civil society organisations related to early education and gathered in an Inter-institutional Working Group, seek to contribute with measures aimed at improving the quality of education from 0 to 6 years of age in Chile.

Effective interactions; initial and continuous training of educators and early childhood technicians; pedagogical leadership; family involvement and process evaluation are the five areas in which the Inter-institutional Roundtable on Early Childhood Education submitted proposals and concrete measures to the government to contribute to improving the quality of teaching in early childhood education.

In each of the five areas mentioned, a brief diagnosis and bibliographical discussion is presented, leading to measures that could be implemented, some of them by the Ministry of Education, others by universities, professional institutes and technical training centres, and even by the educational establishments themselves, as appropriate.

The Undersecretary of Early Childhood Education, María José Castro, valued the work of the Inter-institutional Roundtable, noting that "Chile needs this type of work, from civil society, the private sector and the government to improve Chilean education". Regarding the proposals, she commented that "once again the focus is on the quality of kindergarten education, where there is 100% agreement between what the document proposes and what the government is promoting".

The Inter-institutional Working Group was led by Fundación Educacional Oportunidad, which has been successfully implementing early education strategies in Chilean municipal schools for 10 years. Marcela Marzolo, executive director of the Foundation, highlighted the quality of the proposals and the serious work of the roundtable: "the proposals and measures contained in the document were discussed and agreed upon by organisations with extensive experience in education. As a Foundation, we believe that they can be a real contribution to public policies, as they gather the experience of the field together with the evidence - both national and international - about what we should be doing if we really want to provide quality early education that ensures learning and a harmonious and comprehensive development of the children of our country".

Marcela Bertoglio, director of the School of Kindergarten Education at the Universidad Católica del Maule considers that "it was a consensual work, but with different points of view that aim to improve quality and the processes that we know should be implemented in early education". For her part, Marta Edwards, executive director of the Centro de Estudios para el Desarrollo Psicosocial, assures that "the issue of quality within educational spaces is fundamental, as it is what really impacts on children's learning, and feeling that our proposals are aligned with the Undersecretariat indicates that we are moving in the right direction as a country".

A few months ago, the Ministry received the proposals of "The Initial Plan", of which many of the organisations participating in this roundtable were part, and whose focus was on access, quality and institutionality. The document presented this week focuses exclusively on the quality of early education processes. What is understood by quality education, how it is achieved, how it is measured, who are the actors involved, are some of the questions that this document answers with concrete proposals, being a complement and a deepening of what was presented by El Plan Inicial to the Ministry of Education.

The "Mesa Interinstitucional de Calidad de los Procesos en Educación Inicial" had the active participation of 24 civil society organisations: Acción Educar, Centro de Estudios de Desarrollo y Estimulación Psicosocial (CEDEP), Centro de Estudios Montessori, Centro de Estudios Primera Infancia (CEPI), Centro de Justicia Educacional, Comité para la Infancia y la Familia, Corporación Emprender, Desafío Levantemos Chile, Educación 2020, Educa UC, Elige Educar, Fundación CAP, Fundación Chile, Fundación CMPC, Harvard University, Hogar de Cristo, Fundación Aprendiz, World Organization for Early Childhood Education, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Protectora de la Infancia, Tu Clase Tu País, Universidad Alberto Hurtado, Universidad Católica del Maule and Universidad de las Américas.

THE PROPOSALS

In order to achieve quality interactions, it is proposed to include a specific focus on effective interactions in the Framework for Good Teaching (MBE) for Kindergarten Education and to generate quality in-service training programmes on pedagogical interactions.

In the initial and continuing training of educators and nursery technicians, it is proposed that they respond to the requirements of the establishment and that the institutions that provide the technical career are accredited.

For kindergarten technicians, it is proposed to integrate them into a system that includes guiding standards for technical training and the possibility of professional development within the position with competitive salaries.

It is proposed to diagnose how leadership influences children's learning; to create an early education supplement to the Framework for Good Management and School Leadership (MBDL); for Leadership Centres to train leaders in early education; to establish exclusivity for leadership positions.

Another relevant factor for the roundtable was the participation of families, which is why the creation of learning communities, open days focused on pedagogy and families as facilitators of the learning process are proposed.

Finally, in order to evaluate the quality of processes in early education, the roundtable proposes: to include descriptors of interactions in MBE, an evaluation guideline for expected learning and to consider early education in performance agreements for principals.

Headmasters and principals of 60 municipal schools in the VI Region are trained in sustainability.

In order to maintain the strategies of the Good Start programme over time, directors of municipal schools and school managers from 13 municipalities in the O'Higgins Region attended training given by the area of Continuous Improvement of Fundación Educacional Oportunidad.

Sixty schools from 13 municipalities that make up the Improvement Network of the Good Start programme met to learn about and deepen their knowledge of sustainability tools that will allow them to maintain the strategies and methodologies of the Good Start programme in their classrooms, schools and municipalities over time.

"The objective of this instance is to study and strengthen the sustainability processes experienced by the school and community teams this year 2018 through the delivery of concrete tools for continuous improvement. In this, the management teams and supporters play a fundamental role, as they are the ones who must lead the process that ensures that the strategies and methodologies that worked at the initial level are maintained, making this a continuous process in the classroom, school and commune until quality is fully integrated into the structure and operation", explains Carolina Soto, director of the Foundation's Continuous Improvement area.

During the day, attendees recalled the importance of sustaining strategies to maintain quality, studied their sustainability processes, highlighted the importance of recording specifically in the PHEA (plan, do, evaluate and adjust) improvement cycles to build learning and adjusted ideas or innovations to continue improving in the second half of 2018.

"It has been a great help for us this year and now we want to sustain the strategies, so we are very interested that this programme can be repeated in the other classes and that is why we have attended this training. We have to recognise that this programme has changed early education," said Hernán Barraza, principal of the Mariano Latorre school in Codegua.

Prior to this training, management teams and supporters have received workshops on PHEA continuous improvement cycles, data analysis, the 5 elements theory for sustainability and the 7 levers for leadership.

The objective of all these trainings is to empower management teams and supporters by providing them with the tools to lead improvement processes and implement strategies and methodologies of the Good Start programme to improve teaching and learning autonomously when the Foundation is no longer with them on the ground.

The head of the Chimbarongo DAEM, Víctor Gajardo, values this work with Un Buen Comienzo, "working with the Foundation has been wonderful. We were among the first municipalities to join the programme and it has given us excellent results".

A Good Start is a professional development programme for teachers and managers that seeks to contribute to improving the quality of early education, supporting schools in improving pedagogical and leadership practices so that children can achieve better socio-emotional and language development, and that this 2018 seeks to sustain the strategies delivered in previous years in schools and municipalities.

Innovation in Chilean kindergarten education recognised worldwide

The Carnegie Foundation, one of the leading institutions in educational improvement in the United States, recognises Fundación Educacional Oportunidad by selecting it to be part of the Spotlight on Quality in Continuous Improvement programme, thanks to the Foundation's experience in the use of the continuous improvement methodology in the Chilean educational context and the positive impact of this innovation in school improvement, specifically in the initial level.

Due to the work that Fundación Educacional Oportunidad has been doing for 7 years using the continuous improvement methodology in its early education programme Un Buen Comienzo, the Carnegie Foundation awarded it this year 2018 the outstanding Spotlight category, which will allow it to share its successful strategy with school community leaders, principals, teachers, policy makers, researchers and funders around the world.

The Foundation's Continuous Improvement methodology is based on collaborative work, where each school community tries out ideas for improvement in its own context. After applying them, analysing them and studying the results, they make the necessary adjustments and, if the idea is successful, they share it with their peers through the Foundation's Improvement Network.

Since 2011, the Foundation has been adapting this methodology to the Chilean educational context, working with classroom teams (educators and kindergarten technicians), management teams (principals and heads of UTP) and managers of municipal schools in the Metropolitan and O'Higgins regions in order to turn it into a relevant tool for school improvement. This, together with training and on-site support, has led to improved teaching practices in terms of the quality of interactions and the use of time for pedagogical purposes, specifically in activities that promote language, which has translated into positive results in children's learning. All of this earned Fundación Educacional Oportunidad to be recognised as a 2018 Spotlight by the Carnegie Foundation.

Spotlight on Quality in Continuous Improvement is a Carnegie Foundation programme that seeks to provide clear and powerful examples of the application of improvement principles, methods and tools to solve educational problems worldwide.

"We are proud of this international recognition for these 7 years of systematic work and innovation in Chilean kindergarten education, as it highlights us at a global level alongside five other high-level organisations such as the University of Illinois and the Kipp Foundation. In addition, this recognition implies sharing our strategies, so that they can be replicated by schools and teachers around the world, which fills us with pride, as the spirit of our Foundation is collaborative networking," said Marcela Marzolo, executive director of the Foundation.

Carnegie Foundation and the Spotlight programme

Since 2008, the Carnegie Foundation has been promoting the use of scientific methods of improvement in education and fostering the formation and growth of networked communities. Over the past ten years, thousands of leaders, principals, teachers, policymakers, researchers and administrators around the world have begun to use this methodology. 

Methodical, continuous improvement and networking among teachers and schools around the world have generated new strategies that the Carnegie Foundation has wanted to highlight since 2017 through the Spotlight on Quality in Continuous Improvement programme, and to share with the rest of the world. The programme seeks to provide clear and powerful examples of the application of improvement principles, methods and tools to solve educational problems.

The programme provides educational organisations and improvement networks with the opportunity to learn about quality in continuous improvement, assess their own progress, access resources and education to support improvement, and be recognised for their proven quality practices in the field of education.

Successful results of "Un Buen Comienzo" presented at international education meeting

At the "Annual ProLEER Meeting at Harvard", representatives of Fundación Educacional Oportunidad presented the good results of 10 years of work with pre-kindergarten and kindergarten children in Chilean municipal schools, which are reflected in a book that will be launched next week in our country: "A Good Start for the children of Chile".

Marcela Marzolo, Executive Director of Fundación Educacional Oportunidad, together with Andrea Rolla, Advisor to the Foundation for Harvard University, presented the history, the good results and the lessons learned from the early education programme "Buen Comienzo" at the annual meeting of Proleer at Harvard, which took place this week in Boston.

ProLEER (Professional Learning Network to Advance Early Education Reform) is an international network of researchers, academics, policy makers and programme implementers committed to improving educational practice and policy to raise the quality of early childhood learning. It was founded in 2009 by Harvard University students in collaboration with Professor Catherine Snow of the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

At this meeting, representatives from the United States, the Netherlands, India, Pakistan and Latin America visited a public school in Boston, participated in conferences and shared knowledge and experiences related to education and the situation of education in the different countries represented. Andrea Rolla, Harvard advisor for Fundación Educacional Oportunidad and co-organiser of the event, said that "this is a very important initiative, because it allows us to share experiences, research, and public policies within the region, with Harvard, and internationally". 

Within the framework of the presentations, Marcela Marzolo, Executive Director of the foundation together with Andrea Rolla, presented the book "A Good Start for the children of Chile", a document that describes the history, results, lessons and perspectives of the early education programme A Good Start (UBC), a unique record in Chile, as there are very few rigorous and systematic studies of early education programmes that demonstrate a positive impact on children's learning.

The Good Start programme was designed in 2007 to contribute to Chilean municipal early education and has been evaluated since its inception by the CPCE of the Diego Portales University and the CIAE of the University of Chile, demonstrating its impact on the learning of vulnerable children in early education.

Marcela Marzolo valued the opportunity to present the book and the excellent results of the programme at an international education meeting; "We are happy about the interest in our presentation on the Good Start programme, which only ratifies the international recognition that our work is receiving".

The book, presented at the Boston conference, will be launched in Chile next Tuesday, October 9th at 16:30 hrs. in the Auditorium of the Faculty of Law of the Universidad Diego Portales and will also be attended by the Undersecretary of Early Childhood Education, María José Castro, as well as a talk by Pedro Delgado, an expert in continuous improvement from the Institute from Healthcare Improvement, who will tell how the continuous improvement model was adapted in a unique and innovative way to this early childhood education programme in Chile.

Column: English language teaching does not depend only on a good teacher

Quality classes and committed leaders are no longer enough. English language learning can be achieved when we also have an educational community that actively participates in the teaching of English, from the principals, to the management team, to the parents.

Much is said about how bad we are as a country at teaching English, but little is said about the successful strategies that are being implemented in various parts of Chile and that are enabling students, especially in municipal schools, to learn English from an early age.

When we invite parents to use simple words or ask their children questions and they answer in English, when we send them a whatsapp audio or a simple song communication for them and their children to practice at home, we are involving the family in the teaching process and in this way reinforcing day by day what they learn in the classroom. This is one of the successful strategies of teacher Claudia Gonzalez in Paihuano.

At the Edmundo Vidal Cárdenas school in Vicuña, headmaster Ruperto Pizarro - nominated as one of the 5 best teachers in Chile - is adding other subjects to language teaching. At his school, all teachers reinforce English by asking them to use the language to say hello, ask permission to go to the bathroom, ask for the floor, among other simple expressions. In this way, English is not just one more subject in the curriculum, but extends across the whole school.

When the objective of promoting the teaching of English becomes a communal goal, activities that involve students, teachers, parents and principals are achieved, as is the case in the communes of Vicuña and Paihuano in the Elqui Valley, where during the year they organise poetry contests, English spelling bees and song festivals, in order to include the entire school community and the commune in the teaching of this language. 

Quality classes and committed leaders are no longer enough. English language learning can be achieved when we also have an educational community that actively participates in the teaching of English, from the principals, to the management team, to the parents.

When we have the will and the ideas, but above all when we dare to try them, and even more, when after trying them we reflexively analyse the results and when we share these learnings with others who seek the same objective, we end up generating networking and learning communities.

Marcela Marzolo
Executive Director
Fundación Educacional Oportunidad

English teachers and managers meet to exchange knowledge and experiences

At the 2nd Learning Session of the We Learn early years English teaching programme, teachers, English-speaking professionals, management teams and community directors met to analyse what had been achieved and to plan for the second semester.

Some of the objectives of the 2nd Learning Session of the Improvement Network of the We Learn programme carried out by Fundación Educacional Oportunidad were to share experiences between communes, teachers and directors of 14 basic schools in Paihuano and Vicuña in the Elqui Valley, as well as to analyse the results obtained in the first semester.

There were more than 30 attendees, including teachers, management teams, community teams and English-speaking professionals who shared a day of work on the teaching of English from the early years, exchanging experiences and learning, analysing achievements and planning for the second half of the year.

Cynthia Aránguiz, from the Juan Torres Martínez school in the Diaguitas district of Vicuña, valued the initiative because "each time I leave with a backpack full of ideas that I can apply in different classes. The best result is that the children have grown fond of the subject and now see it as an important tool for their future.

The activity was attended by the Provincial Head of Education Ianina Erazo, who highlighted the Learning Session stating that "I think that this meeting and the network is an excellent opportunity for continuous improvement in the teaching of this language. For us as a government, the teaching of English is of paramount importance and the work of the Foundation through this programme is in line with our educational objectives".

Since 2011, the Foundation has been working with the Continuous Improvement Methodology in the Metropolitan and VI regions, which involves collaborative work between the schools that are part of the programme and the implementation of improvement cycles to test ideas (Plan, Do, Study and Adjust). In 2017, this methodology was incorporated into the We Learn programme.

In this line of work of continuous improvement, collaboration and the exchange of experiences and learning between teachers and principals is fundamental, with the Learning Sessions being the ideal instance for this to happen. "It is very valuable for the management teams and for the teachers, as the collaborative work allows them to analyse and look for strategies to improve the teaching of English in the valley," said teacher Miguel Ángel Domínguez, from the Jerónimo Godoy Villanueva school in the town of Pisco Elqui in Paihuano.

The We Learn programme of Fundación Educacional Oportunidad focuses on the professional development of teachers and principals with a view to improving the quality of English teaching from an early age and has been accompanying the educational communities of the Elqui Valley for more than 12 years. Peter Morse, member of the board of the Fundación Educacional Oportunidad, highlighted the motivation of the teachers and management teams in the programme. "I see that they have a very positive attitude, how they create their own ideas and use the tools provided by the Foundation to improve their work day by day. It has been a very useful and enjoyable day," said the director.

This is the second of three annual sessions of the continuous improvement work of the We Learn programme in the Elqui Valley, which this year also added the teaching of this language to the 1st and 2nd year students of the Mistraliano secondary school in Paihuano and the Edmundo Vidal Cárdenas school in Vicuña, through Access, a programme that is carried out in conjunction with the US Embassy and with the support of English-speaking professionals from Beyond English.